28 June 2009 @ 05:11 pm
 
Spoilers/review for Fate of the Jedi: Omen~



Nice first shot, Christie Golden. I am impressed.

I am awful at discussing books as they go in chronological order, so here we go:

Kesh. I saw "FORGOTTEN PLANET OF SITH" in a summary and shook my head. But this was actually executed well. It's interesting to see a Sith Order who are different from the one we're used to. They raise families, support each other, and create bonds. They're definitely malovent, but it's going to be hard to see them as traditionally evil as Sidious or Caedus. There's lots of potential for ~the grey side~ to come into play once they make contact with the greater GFFA. I'm not sure how I feel about Vespara. She has more depth than I anticipated.

The GA. What I'm really loving about this series is how impartial I find myself being toward "the bad guys." It's awesome to see galactic politics so shaken up -- I never thought I'd be rooting for the character who tortured the main heroes decades earlier. But FOTJ is answering questions that have been asked for a while now; mainly, why do the Jedi expect to be hero worshipped, if the galaxy has been screwed over time and time again by Force-based religious fanaticism? Why should they have special allowances made?

And I was beyond thrilled in Outcast when Luke agreed. He wasn't haughty or in disbelief about his sentence. No "side" was fully in the right or wrong, and they sat down and reached an agreement which rattled Coruscant but was still the best decision for everyone.

Back to Omen. Deciding for the GA and Order to each have two sick Jedi is another show of fairness, even though that decision was hard to reach.

Daala is interesting. Regardless of whether she has ulterior motives or not, I think... she really does care about the general populace. You guys can tar and feather me for saying that, it's okay. :|

Luke and Ben. George, can we have a show just about the two of them? Please? I don't know if I can even somewhat-eloquently describe how much I adore the Skywalker men together. They're both still picking up the pieces, and seeing their struggles with both Mara and Jacen's deaths is beautiful. There's so much sadness at Luke being there for Ben when all Luke ever wanted at his son's age was a real father of his own, and Ben... knows this. Luke Skywalker is his hero now. He's starting to maturely shake the stigma of being a Skywalker that haunted him when he was younger, and is realizing that it's not that bad.

Ben attempted to flow-walk in the same spot where Jacen learned how to do it. He tried to warn him about the future, but obviously, it was futile. He went back to Luke, ashamed, and man, I like this kid a lot.

And obviously, all Mara mentions punch me right in the gut. Especially the mentions of her "making the trip along with them."

Han and Leia. Leia kicks so much ass in this book, it's amazing. Fiercest grandmother ever. And there's a great bit that caught me off guard which confirms Leia having long-lasting childhood memories of Breha. Again, unexpected. Han... stands around a lot and makes jokes. Jokes that made me smile, at least. They are cute.

Han and Leia's parenting.

......

............

...................

...... brb drawing a chart. Good luck Allana? :D?

Allana. I don't know if I like her or Ben better. She is the cutest SW child. I honestly don't know at this point if she's less stable than Jacen at her age, or more, or just the same. The comment about her smiling and being quiet when Han and Leia tried to talk to her about bad things bothered me a hell of a lot, but, at least Han and Leia tried talking to begin with, and they listened to her. Her idea about what to do with nexu cubs was relieving. At least she'd spent her time after a traumatic situation constructively and with a level head.

It's disturbing to know now that Ship was talking to her in Outcast. I hope it's able to talk to ALL Force-sensitives and not... just... :\

And the possible parallels about loving animals... uhh. I am going to go into my Safety Cubby and tell myself it's something common amongst ALL children. Yes. Okay.

Jaina and Jag. Awww. I really don't have that much of an opinion, but Han likes Jag, so I like Jag. At first I thought, "Eugh, could Jaina really still be herself with him?" when it was semi-official that this would happen. But showing Captain Cardboard's personality, the part of him that Jaina loves, is helping a lot. They're a good match. I think my acceptance comes from the Moffs hating him. A+ proposal, Mr. Fel.

Overall. "Needs moar Mirax" is my only selfish complaint. This book was fantastic and the whole series is reminding me that this era can be fun. It's making me excited for the post-ROTJ EU again. The editors at Del Ray make statements about wanting a more "grown-up", "realistic" galaxy, and for the first time, I'm enjoying it. If you've been disillusioned with the EU lit for a while now, I highly recommend you start in on this. It's nowhere NEAR as fire-and-brimstone as was predicted.

HEY DON'T LEAVE YET



I keep saying, "Okay, it's no one's fault that Nat went crazy and Allana had to watch helpless animals she wanted for pets get slaughtered," but MAYBE THEY SHOULD PLAY CANDYLAND WITH HER INSTEAD. OR. ENROLL HER IN SCHOOL. OR SOMETHING.
 
 
( 27 comments — Post a new comment )
pronker: applaudbunny[info]pronker on June 29th, 2009 12:42 am (UTC)
jaslfjdfyourchartjflajfdasl=terrific. I remember reading the 'kids-kidnapped-all-the-time' books and wondering about parenting skills of both Han and Leia; maybe the Junior Jedi Knights books show them at a better stage of the game?
groove, slam, work it back[info]niicoly on June 29th, 2009 01:07 am (UTC)
There's still a bit of detachment when the kids are older and away at the Academy. Then during the YV war, it gets even worse, especially when Han briefly leaves Leia. After they get back together and Anakin dies, there's an "OMG, what have we done," moment, and they start being much better parents.

But it's a little too late, at any rate, because that's when Jacen started to break. I think they're definitely better parents to Allana now, but I don't know if it's just because they have a lot more time to dedicate to her, or because they've REALLY learned from their mistakes.
pronker: otbw[info]pronker on June 29th, 2009 01:57 am (UTC)
There comes a point to Yoda-ize: "Quality time, there is not. Quantity time, there needs to be." Allana gets the benefit of their, um, retirement, I guess?
groove, slam, work it back[info]niicoly on June 29th, 2009 02:23 am (UTC)
Plenty of time for... field trips. To Kessel. :\
Jenny: concert[info]chlorrel on June 29th, 2009 01:28 am (UTC)
I think I've given up on their parenting long ago. But it might help in Allana's favor that she has her great uncle and her aunt and cousin and all these other older family members to inspire and guide her as well.

Also, your summary on Kesh and the GA summarized a lot of my opinions as well. It's all much better executed, I think, than Legacy was. And I think you know my opinion on J/J.

But yeah. Still A+ series, huh?
groove, slam, work it back[info]niicoly on June 29th, 2009 02:09 am (UTC)
I think what's hard for me is that H&L have admitted their mistakes, BUT THEY KEEP MAKING THEM. But yes, it's great that Allana has so many other relatives in her life. I think Jaina especially can keep her in line. She knows how it is to be a young Solo girl. :\

Yeah. Legacy just didn't seem organized.

It's going really well. I... can't wait to see H&L's ~*~*REACTION*~*~.
Jenny: hiya[info]chlorrel on June 29th, 2009 04:15 pm (UTC)
I do think they're trying a bit harder this time around. For one thing, they really are looking to keep Allana more settled . But they're just so used to being in the spotlight and interfering that it's hard.

I am SO looking forward to Han's reaction you have no idea. You also don't know how tempted I am to do a post in A42 with Jaina reading this book.
groove, slam, work it back[info]niicoly on June 30th, 2009 12:31 am (UTC)
ifdjglkdljgdlfkjgdjfkg

DO IT. She might, uhh, not being the only one reading it.
Jenny: hunny mori NOT otp[info]chlorrel on June 30th, 2009 01:20 am (UTC)
Just as a warning, I have been very sporadic with tagging lately. But I shall make post?
groove, slam, work it back[info]niicoly on June 30th, 2009 01:46 am (UTC)
Yaay. And no worries -- I'm going out to dinner tonight, but I'll be around for most of tomorrow.
ELtheGeneral: :1 icon of Threep[info]elthegeneral on June 29th, 2009 01:31 am (UTC)
SLDJAFLKSJGSLFGSFDG.
THEEPIO WILL RAISE THEM.
groove, slam, work it back: THE WORST ICON EVER[info]niicoly on June 29th, 2009 02:09 am (UTC)
Re: SLDJAFLKSJGSLFGSFDG.
HE'S GONNA WASH THE TAUNTAUN HE'S GONNA WASH THE TAUNTAUN HE'S GONNA WASH THE TAUNTAUN HE'S GONNA WASH THE TAUNTAUN HE'S GONNA WASH THE TAUNTAUN HE'S GONNA WASH THE TAUNTAUN HE'S GONNA WASH THE TAUNTAUN HE'S GONNA WASH THE TAUNTAUN HE'S GONNA WASH THE TAUNTAUN HE'S GONNA WASH THE TAUNTAUN HE'S GONNA WASH THE TAUNTAUN HE'S GONNA WASH THE TAUNTAUN HE'S GONNA WASH THE TAUNTAUN HE'S GONNA WASH THE TAUNTAUN HE'S GONNA WASH THE TAUNTAUN HE'S GONNA WASH THE TAUNTAUN




HAN SAYS SO
DARTH NICKELS[info]polly_moopers on June 29th, 2009 01:34 am (UTC)
HA HA HA HA THAT CHART

These books sound too sad for me, t/y for the rundown about my Anakin's great granddaughter
groove, slam, work it back[info]niicoly on June 29th, 2009 02:11 am (UTC)
They're actually kinda fun or maybe I have just desensitized myself Polly.
Possibly a Little Too Awesome: jaina[info]amphetamine_47 on June 29th, 2009 01:56 am (UTC)
LOL, greatest flowchart evah!

Yes. PLEASE do something normal for Amelia. Public school or...play dates or something. Cripes.

And Jaina and Jag make me squee! :D
groove, slam, work it back[info]niicoly on June 29th, 2009 02:15 am (UTC)
It's like... even taking her to get a pet has to be something horrible. D

Jaina and Jag are great. I think Jag needs her more than he thinks.
[info]helenquest on June 29th, 2009 01:57 am (UTC)
OMG. YOU DO LOVE CHARTS.
Great review!

I'm entirely "meh" about the Jaina/Jag stuff only b/c I've just prepared myself that every Skywalker will be miserable at some point.


If I had a series of books, cartoons, television shows, radio dramas, plays, sing-a-longs devoted to the Skywalker boys, I would be as happy as a pig in shit. Their dynamic is what makes me want to read these books.
groove, slam, work it back[info]niicoly on June 29th, 2009 02:20 am (UTC)
SEE I TOLD YOUUU.
It's very true. But ehhh they can be miserable together?

So like my favorite part is all the comparisons Luke makes to Ben about him at that age. I CAN'T WAIT FOR HIM TO GROW UP. OMG.
Scrambles the Death Dealer[info]citizenjess on June 29th, 2009 03:22 am (UTC)
THANK YOU FOR TELLING ME THAT HAN AND LEIA ARE SUCH GOOD PARENTS SO I DON'T HAVE TO READ THE POST-EU BOOKS
groove, slam, work it back[info]niicoly on June 29th, 2009 04:16 am (UTC)
PARENTS OF THE YEAR
Scrambles the Death Dealer[info]citizenjess on June 29th, 2009 08:16 am (UTC)
I MEANT POST-OT EU BUT WHATEV
IT'S THE PONIES' MATING SEASON
Polarity: Darth Maul- only power[info]pinkpolarity on June 29th, 2009 10:45 am (UTC)
The flowchart got cut off the side of my browser. I'll have to try viewing later from a different computer and see if that makes a difference. Too bad, it looked funny! :(

I'm really, really intrigued by this review, I hope my library gets this soon. I'm especially interested in what they do with the Sith. I've got Sith Fatigue, and it's sad because they've been my main SW fannish interest-- they've just overused them so much and they're so *unlike* the Sith I love best (the ancient racial Sith in the TOTJ comics). Those, too, are very unlike Palpy's kind of Sith, they were a stable civilization for over a millennium (and I've been doing lots of RPG worldbuilding ever since to figure out from the hints in the comics what they do differently that let them make it while every other iteration of the Sith have killed each other or been limited to two people). So I really, really want to read this!

Word on the Luke-and-Ben show in general, Ben has been my one consistent bright spot in a really lousy series (LotF) and I absolutely adored him in Outcast. Also agree with what you're saying about the gov't reaction to the Jedi. Said pretty much the same thing in the review I did of Outcast, that non-Force-sensitives have been pretty well hosed by internal Force-sect wars for thousands of years now, it's astonishing that this didn't come *sooner*.

I'm encouraged by this review, thanks for posting it! I loved the NJO and have felt let down by everything since-- but Outcast was pretty good, so hopefully this is the start of brighter times for the EU.
groove, slam, work it back[info]niicoly on June 30th, 2009 12:37 am (UTC)
To be honest, I never knew anything about the ancient Sith until I read this book, and even they are just a small sect. I'm really interested.

Ben is just incredible. There's a lot of him that reminds me of Anakin Solo, but their paths are so different now.

I'm glad you're liking the series as well :D And yes, I agree that it should have come sooner. This is the type of realism I'm enjoying, as well as the paparazzi, for example.

Word on brighter times. I'm not looking for unicorns and rainbows, I just want something that makes sense and hasn't been done before.
Tenna { i will holler you home }: [ sw - insane! ][info]tenel_ka on June 29th, 2009 11:18 pm (UTC)
LOL still haven't bothered with the series at all but THAT FLOW CHART KIND OF MAKES ME WANT TO MUAHAHAH TOO TRUE. XD
groove, slam, work it back[info]niicoly on June 30th, 2009 12:41 am (UTC)
YOU SHOULD, IF ONLY FOR THE LULZ. BUT OMEN HAS A SMALL TK MENTION~ And omg, the Jacen flashback was so poignant. Poor silly boy just wanted to do the right thing. And Ben knew. :(((((

OTHER GOOD JACEN THINGS:

- Leia has a lotttt of guilt
- More references to Jaina telling her family that he was Jacen again at the end
- Luke and Ben are very careful to differentiate between "Jacen" and "Caedus" when discussing him. UNLIKE WOOKIEEPEDIA. >(
Red 5 Standing By[info]rustyredux on June 30th, 2009 05:41 am (UTC)
THIS IS THE GREATEST FLOW CHART KNOWN TO MANNNNNNNNNNNN
groove, slam, work it back[info]niicoly on June 30th, 2009 05:44 am (UTC)
YAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY THANK YOU I LOVE IT TOO

Edited at 2009-06-30 05:44 am (UTC)